I was invited to attend the above three day conference by Prof
Hans-Joachim von Kondratowitz of Berlin in order to moderate a session
on ‘Migration as Impact on Ageing Mediterranean Welfare Societies’. It
was held at the Imperial Hotel (more of which later) in Sliema, a
popular residential suburb of Valletta.
The conference was attended by 29 delegates, just
over half of whom came from countries with a Mediterranean coastline.
Not all the Mediterranean rim countries were represented but those who
attended included academics from France, Italy, Israel, Greece, Lebanon,
Tunisia and of course, Malta. There were several delegates from
non-Mediterranean countries including Portugal, Sweden, Norway, The
Netherlands, Germany, Czech Republic, Belgium, the USA and the UK. In
the opening session, there was an interesting discussion on which
countries do indeed represent ‘Mediterranean’ cultures. For example,
Parisians rarely consider themselves ‘ Mediterranean’, but the
Portuguese, who do not have a Mediterranean coast, certainly consider
themselves part of the Mediterranean culture. There were other dilemmas
pertinent to identifying a ‘Mediterranean culture’. The coastline spans
three continents: Europe, Asia and Africa, and represents the three
principal monotheistic religions of Christianity, Judaism and Islam. The
region also contains a wide diversity in socio-economic status,
political and welfare systems and demographic profiles. There are even
greater disparities in the status of women, young and old, which impacts
substantially on family responsibilities for and by the older
generations.
The extremely interesting papers ranged from general topics such as
household and family structure; demographic patterns and predictions;
dependency in old age; employment opportunities; pension provision
across the region, to more specific topics such as social relations and
social networks (Israel); present and future health (Greece and
Lebanon); home care arrangements and family responsibilities (Portugal);
illegal/unregistered unqualified migrant care workers (Italy) and legal
registered unqualified migrant carers (Israel); and migrant populations
growing older in a host country (France). The conference concluded with
a round table discussion with invited presentations from academics from
Germany and Norway who outlined the topics, suggested gaps and where
and how research might be taken forward.
Each presentation stressed the centrality of caring for older people
within the family, as a duty and obligation enshrined in religious
practice and the law. It was equally stressed particularly in the
Islamic culture, that such obligations are taken on completely willingly
out of love and respect for their elders, and an acknowledgment that
the physical care was carried out by daughters-in-law, daughters and
nieces. Although there was a slightly more ambivalent attitude to the
‘hands on’ aspect of family (female) responsibilities from the Roman
Catholic and from the Israeli presenters (where carers were employed to
look after extremely frail elderly parents), there was nevertheless a
recognition that the overall management of care rests concretely within
the family.
The overwhelming ‘take home’ message is that the
eastern and southern shore – non-European countries of the Mediterranean
are beginning to follow the demographic patterns of their northern
neighbours inasmuch as they are experiencing dramatically decreasing
fertility rates and increasing life expectancy. It goes without saying
that there will therefore be fewer adult children to share the
responsibility of care for longer living parents. As important, is the
increasing rate of female employment in all these countries with the
concomitant reduced availability of adult daughters/in-law to provide
round the clock care for very frail and sick older people. In the
southern states of Europe, particularly Italy, this gap is filled by
cheap, hugely exploited and unregulated 24/7 female labour part paid for
by state subsidies. These migrants are tolerated by the governments
because they fulfil a vital role in caring for the ageing population. In
the countries without state support for the care of older people, there
is, or will be, a substantial structural lag between what is happening
in society in terms of women’s choices in life, and formalised state
help forthcoming for the older population. At some stage, support for
elder social care must be available as well as the health and pension
provision increasingly recognised as a state welfare responsibility in
the region.
From a northern European social democratic welfare
gerontological perspective (mine), what also unfolded was the apparent
powerlessness of older men and women in choices about how or where they
wished to live, especially when they were bereaved. Although as
mentioned, almost all the papers stressed the importance of duty,
obligation and respect to older people, none put forward the perspective
of the older people themselves or for that matter, their female carers.
In the round table discussion, I pointed out that the Mediterranean
countries do not have the monopoly on loving, respecting and caring for
their older parents, and also that nothing had been discussed about
older people who had no family to care for them.
It wouldn’t be a proper report from me if I didn’t give you some of the
context of the conference. The Maltese Islands are steeped in history
and have standing stone and temples which predate Stonehenge and the
pyramids. As an important crossroad in the Mediterranean, it has enjoyed
and suffered a multitude of conquerors and governors. It had a mainly
good and amicable relationship with the UK for over one and a half
centuries and there are many relics of ‘British’ rule including English
being widely spoken, red phone and letter boxes. One such relic is the
Imperial Hotel in which the conference was held. A most impressive
building of great character with a fabulous ‘reception’ area, stunning
sweeping staircases either side, a lovely courtyard and swimming pool
and excellent conference facilities. The accommodation was a little
‘tired’ and the cuisine left much to be desired, but the atmosphere at
the conference was highly convivial and well worth the journey.