David Jolley MSc FRCPsych
Consultant Psychiatrist and Honorary Reader in Old Age Psychiatry
Dementia is a syndromal concept. It is characterized by acquired and
often progressive cognitive deficits, including impairment of memory and
new learning, together with additional changes in aspects of
personality. Although seen in some people in middle age, it becomes more
common in very late life (20% plus in 80+ age groups) where
differentiation from the natural, non-pathological aspects of ageing may
be difficult or controversial. The categorical ‘diagnosis’ of dementia
is in reality based on arbitrarily set cut-offs of function measured on
valid and reliable scales and reflecting an accumulation of underlying
pathologies, the most common of which is Alzheimer change, followed by
cerebro-vascular disease, Lewy Body disease and Fronto-temporal
dementia.
Whilst most people prefer to live in their own
private household throughout life, dementia so undermines personal
competence that 40% percent of people with dementia are housed in
residential or nursing homes at any one time and more than 70 percent
will be in institutional care at the time of dying.
Whist health and social care needs have been met
over many centuries by faith organizations, the tradition of Health and
Social Care in the UK provided by Government and Local Government, has
largely excluded the spiritual dimension of health and illness from
consideration in recent decades. It is absent from training and has been
all-but taboo in practice. Yet personal spirituality is central to the
experience and quality of life for the majority of individuals and for
many this is framed within a system of faith belief and practices. These
are particularly exercised at times of stress, including illness which
produces altered self image and competence and carries the prospect of
departure and death.
Sarah Mullally (now Reverend
Dame) did a great deal during her nursing career to encourage the
re-introduction of respect and knowledge of spirituality and faith
within health care.
Neil Moreland considers the
phenomenon of dementia and its impact on individuals and their carers
from the perspective of those who cherish their spirituality and that of
others, but do so without a framework in a Faith.
Clive Baldwin addresses the use
of language associated with spiritual experience and faith and relates
this to approaches which encourage holistic and person-centred care in
dementia. Explorations of these may lead us some way toward a better
understanding of the nature of spirituality and its relationship to
faith and religious belief.
Rob Merchant has researched
Judeo-Christian approaches to the care and ministry of vulnerable and
impaired older people from antiquity – seeking to glean lessons learned
which might be transferable into a modern context and understanding of
the scenarios.
Richard Allen looks at the
present range of spirituality and faith as represented amongst older
people and families living in the UK. This includes a range of Faiths
and Religions as well as a spectrum of spirituality/non-spirituality and
Faith/non-Faith with intergenerational schisms.
Our questions:
- How do these affect understandings of the experience of dementia and dementia care?
- How are these to be interpreted to provide
appropriate spiritual care for individuals, families and other carers in
the face of progressive dementia and the approach of death?